How to Know If It’s Real Remorse or Just Damage Control: Rebuilding Trust After an Affair
If your partner cheated and says they’re sorry, how do you know if it’s real remorse—or just damage control?
And if you’re the one who was betrayed, how do you ever learn to trust again, when the person who hurt you is the one who used to feel like home?
As a couples therapist, I’ve sat with dozens of partners facing that exact question. And the truth is: recovering from an affair isn’t about forgiveness. It’s about rebuilding safety. And that takes real accountability, emotional presence, and deep repair work.
This blog post is a full breakdown of what real remorse looks like, what it means to heal from infidelity, and how you can create a relationship that’s stronger on the other side.
Trust Isn’t Just Damaged—It’s Shattered
Affairs are what therapists call attachment trauma. Dr. Janis Abrahms Spring, author of After the Affair, explains that infidelity shatters the betrayed partner’s assumptive world: the sense that their relationship is safe, secure, and built on shared reality.
Suddenly, nothing feels certain anymore.
Research from the Gottman Institute shows that betrayal isn’t only about sex—it’s about secrecy, emotional avoidance, and eroded connection. Often, infidelity is a protest against feeling unseen or disconnected. But make no mistake: it’s a traumatic act that fractures the very foundation of the relationship.
If the person who had the affair wants to repair, the first thing they must understand is this: your partner doesn’t just feel hurt. They feel unsafe.
What Real Remorse Actually Looks Like
Real remorse isn’t a one-time apology. It’s not just guilt or saying, “I didn’t mean to hurt you.” It’s emotional accountability in action.
In the Gottmans’ model of recovery, this is the Atonement Phase. In Janis Spring’s work, this is where remorse must be earned.
Here’s what that looks like:
1. Full Accountability
No excuses. No blame. Not, “I cheated because you were distant,” or “I felt neglected.” The affair was a choice. Owning that choice is step one.
2. Transparency Without Defensiveness
You may need to open up access to texts, calendars, or your social media accounts. The point isn’t control. It’s helping your partner rebuild a felt sense of security.
3. Curiosity About Your Partner’s Pain
Real repair requires empathy. That means holding space for their grief, anger, or numbness without shutting down or turning it back on yourself.
4. Repeated Demonstrations of Safety
Trust is rebuilt through small moments of consistency: showing up, staying grounded, and becoming emotionally reliable again.
From an attachment lens, this is about helping your partner feel safe in your presence. You become the source of co-regulation: the person who helps soothe the very nervous system you hurt.
Betrayal Triggers Trauma Responses
Betrayal activates intense nervous system responses: panic, flashbacks, emotional shutdown, rage, and intrusive thoughts.
Spring calls these trauma echoes.
These are symptoms of the attachment system being thrown into alarm mode. They’re not dramatics. They’re survival responses.
If you’re the betrayed partner, you may feel anxious, numb, hypervigilant, or stuck in obsessive loops. If you’re the one who strayed, your job is not to defend. Your job is to stay. To breathe slowly, offer grounding, and help regulate your partner’s pain—not add to it.
This process is brutal. But it’s possible.
How Trust Is Actually Rebuilt
Apologies don’t restore trust. Embodied consistency does.
The Gottmans call this creating rituals of connection. Spring insists that forgiveness must be earned through sustained, relational repair.
Here’s what helps:
Full disclosure—without trickle-truth
Shared passwords, calendars, or access to reduce anxiety
Gratitude and acknowledgment: “Thank you for staying.” “I know this is hard.”
Daily check-ins: “How are you feeling about us today?”
It may feel uncomfortable to offer that level of openness. But right now, you are rebuilding the architecture of emotional safety. And that means going beyond what you’ve done before.
Why You Can’t Rush Healing
Research shows that affair recovery takes 2 to 5 years.
Let that sink in.
Not 2 to 5 months. Not a few therapy sessions. Years.
And that’s only if both partners are committed to deep, vulnerable work.
If the partner who cheated starts to say:
“Why can’t you just get over it?”
“I already said I’m sorry.”
“This is just making it worse.”
That tells you they’re still focused on their comfort—not your safety. Healing can’t be rushed. It’s not a checklist. It’s a co-created, long-term process.
How to Rebuild Structure and Shared Safety
Structure is what holds a relationship together when emotion is unpredictable.
What that might look like:
Weekly emotional check-ins
Agreed-upon boundaries around outside relationships
Rituals of affection, gratitude, and reflection
Open dialogue about needs and triggers
These aren’t just nice ideas—they’re part of what therapists call secure-functioning relationships, where both partners commit to co-creating a system of mutual protection.
Why Both Partners Need Individual Work
The Betrayed Partner needs support for:
Anger and grief
Processing trauma symptoms
Rebuilding self-trust
The Betraying Partner needs:
Insight into why they betrayed
Awareness of their conflict style, attachment patterns, and avoidance
A support system to stay accountable to their growth
It’s not your partner’s job to keep you on track. That’s your job.
Shame vs. Responsibility
Shame says: “I’m a terrible person.” Responsibility says: “I caused pain, and I’m here to repair it.”
Shame spirals often make things worse. They pull the betraying partner inward. But repair requires showing up outwardly.
This isn’t about you being good or bad. It’s about you being safe or not.
Don’t Keep Score. Don’t Deflect.
One of the most toxic responses to betrayal is this:
“Well, you weren’t perfect either.”
Even if it’s true, it’s not helpful.
Now is not the time for comparisons. It’s the time for compassion. Repair is about taking ownership, not pointing fingers.
Normalize the Emotional Whiplash
You might feel numb one day and furious the next. You might cry in the morning and feel nothing by night.
That’s not dysfunction. That’s grief.
You’re mourning the relationship you thought you had. And no matter where this leads, those feelings deserve space.
When to Explore the Root Causes
Eventually, both partners need to explore why the disconnection happened. But not too soon.
In After the Affair, Spring cautions: this step only comes after emotional safety is re-established. If you try to process the relationship dynamics too early, it can deepen the trauma.
But when the time is right, you can ask:
What needs were unmet in our connection?
What emotions went unspoken?
What roles did we each play in growing distant—not in the betrayal, but in the disconnection?
That’s how you co-create what many couples call Marriage 2.0—a relationship built on clarity, boundaries, and shared growth.
Final Thoughts
You are not broken if you stay. You are not weak if you leave. You are not crazy for still feeling hurt, even years later.
Real remorse isn’t about words. It’s about presence, accountability, and becoming someone trustworthy again—one moment at a time.
Let this be the beginning of something honest. Let it be the first step toward safety. Let it be a relationship that was worth rebuilding.
Need Help Rebuiling After An Affair? Let’s Talk
